A screening of “Israelism,” a documentary exploring shifting perspectives on Jewish identity, particularly among younger generations was held on Wednesday, Feb. 26 at Colgate University. The film examined how Jewish communities, especially in the U.S, are reassessing their relationship with Israel.
The documentary’s about page described the film.
“When two young American Jews raised to unconditionally love Israel witness the brutal way Israel treats Palestinians, their lives take sharp left turns. They join a movement of young American Jews battling the old guard to redefine Judaism’s relationship with Israel, revealing a deepening generational divide over modern Jewish identity.” the website states.
The documentary featured interviews with a diverse group of voices, including Jewish individuals with varying views on Israel, former Israeli soldiers, scholars and Palestinian activists. It also focused on the generational divide in Jewish perspectives, with younger individuals beginning to question traditional pro-Israel beliefs and older generations often remaining connected to pro-Israel movements.
A key focus of “Israelism” is critiquing programs such as Birthright Israel, which provides free trips to Israel for young Jewish people. The film suggests that these programs present an idealized image of Israel while omitting discussions of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Former Israeli soldiers interviewed in the documentary shared their experiences in the military, reflecting on how their training shaped their understanding of Palestinians. Meanwhile, Palestinian interviewees described the Israeli military presence as intimidating and oppressive.
The film also addressed the broader historical context of Zionism, discussing its significance in Jewish identity following the Holocaust and the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948. According to Britannica, Zionism is a “Jewish nationalist movement with the goal of the creation and support of a Jewish national state in Palestine.” While some interviewees in the documentary argue that unwavering support for Israel has long been a defining feature of Jewish identity, others advocate for a more critical and nuanced approach.
After the film, attendees shared in a group discussion and dinner that sparked reflection on the complexities of Jewish identity and the broader geopolitical debate surrounding Israel and Palestine. Some viewers praised the documentary’s emotional impact and emphasis on contemporary issues, while others noted its limited focus on historical context and the lack of diverse pro-Israel perspectives.
Noah Dauber, associate professor of political science and director of the Jewish studies program, was one such critic of the film.
“The film understates diversity in the Jewish community about Israeli politics,” Dauber said.
In terms of educational experience, the film screening received positive feedback. First-year Sophia Luzietti appreciated the opportunity the screening provided to learn.
“I think it had a lot of useful insights on both perspectives of the conflict and clearly showed how ideas change through lived experiences and differ across generations,” Luzietti said. “I think I walked away from the screening feeling more informed on both the historical aspects of the conflict and the debates surrounding it.”
Another attendee, first-year Maddie Mason, believed the film was important for all students to watch.
“I think that the film and similar films should be required for all students. Having an understanding of international politics is extremely important,” Mason said.
The screening was co-sponsored by Colgate University’s Peace and Conflict Department, University Museums, Women’s, Gender, and Sexuality Studies, and the Central New Jersey Chapter of Jewish Voice for Peace.
